Originally found and named by Nova, he tried to feed it acorns and bring it back to his home. Eventually Nova managed to trap Jesus which caused him to have a minor seizure, to Nova and Seamus' amusement. They both defended Jesus' cage through the night, only to have him escape his cage a short while after. Jesus left them to be with a female bunny. Jesus and his female bunny were soon murdered by Nova in his rage.
Nova soon captured another bunny who he named Jesus 2. The next morning, Nova and Seamus went underground, leaving Jesus 2. It is unknown if he died or escaped, as his predecessor.
Later in his Minecraft:Quad Mountain Survival Nova tamed a turtle from the Mo' Creatures mod and named him Jesus(the heading says Jesus 3 but he is just named Jesus.) As of 6/16/2012 he is alive and healthy but still mourning the loss of his twin brother Matt Damon.